How to Decide Between Anodizing, Painting, and Powder ...

CHOOSING THE RIGHT COATING FOR YOUR ALUMINUM

Anodizing | Organic Coatings | Recommendations | Conclusions

Check now

Deciding between anodizing, painting, and powder coating for aluminum finishes depends on several factors including durability, cost, appearance, and application environment. Based on Google’s top search result, choosing the right coating often involves considering various benefits and limitations of each option. This article aims to guide you through the process of selecting the appropriate finish for architectural aluminum, whether it’s for metal roofing, storefronts, or curtainwalls. For direct specification information, you can also visit How to Specify Anodized and Painted Finishes.

What Is Anodizing?

Anodizing is a straightforward electrochemical process that enhances aluminum by creating a protective layer of aluminum oxide on its surface. The lifespan of this finish increases with the thickness of the anodic coating applied. This coating is durable, weather-resistant, and tightly bonded to the aluminum, ensuring it won't peel or flake off.

1. Generally more cost-effective than painting except for coil-painted products.
2. Harder than PVDF or FEVE, making it ideal for high-traffic areas.
3. Cannot peel off as it is part of the metal structure.
4. Provides a rich metallic look, with color that can be controlled better through advanced color matching techniques.
5. Unaffected by sunlight; contrasts with organic coatings that degrade under UV light.

However, improperly sealed anodizing can exhibit poor chemical resistance. It's crucial to ensure thicker coatings to prolong durability, especially for exterior applications.

Anodizing & the Environment

Anodizing aligns well with current environmental concerns. It often meets stringent environmental regulations more easily than other metal finishing processes. Municipal wastewater treatment facilities can even benefit from aluminum sulfate byproducts. Anodizing involves no VOCs or heavy metals, making it a relatively eco-friendly option.

ORGANIC COATINGS

Aluminum organic coatings' performance depends on pretreatment, resin, and pigmentation. Factory-applied coatings offer superior results due to better-controlled conditions. Resins, like PVDF, provide excellent weather resistance, while others, such as epoxy, are suited for interior use only. AAMA 2605-17a sets stringent performance benchmarks for spray-coated aluminum.

A notable attribute of AAMA 2605-17a is its requirement for a decade-long exposure in South Florida conditions. PVDF coatings, formulated as a mix of 70% PVDF and 30% other resins (mostly acrylics), are known for their UV and chemical resistance, making them popular in metal roofing and curtainwall applications.

1. PVDF is chemically inert and lasts longer in corrosive environments than anodizing.
2. Offers a vast array of colors and can be produced in small batches efficiently.
3. Better color consistency than anodizing though slight variations are still possible.

Powder Coatings

Powder paint encases pigment in powdered resin, eliminating the solvent typical in liquid paints. This feature reduces air pollution as curing powder emits no VOCs. However, powder coatings generally require larger batch sizes. Polyester TGIC powders lead in stock color availability and offer considerable durability, although they may lack gloss retention compared to PVDF powders.

One distinctive advantage of powder coatings is their reduced environmental impact. Powder coatings have become competitive alternatives to anodized and solvent-based coatings.

Environmental Considerations in a Coating Choice

Both solvent-borne and powder coating formulations can be manufactured from various resins. Solvent-borne coatings, however, pose air pollution risks due to VOC emissions. Stringent regulations, such as the Clean Air Act, are pushing the industry towards more eco-friendly options, pushing up solvent-based coating costs consequently.

The industry might lean towards powder coatings for reducing air pollution and adhering to future regulations.

Recommendations For Curtainwall & Metal Roof Coating

PVDF coatings are often the go-to for curtainwalls and metal roofing because their color stability and selection range often surpass their need for abrasion resistance. Ensuring uniformity in coating application is crucial to avoid color variation problems.

Anodizing may be preferred for its rich, metallic look. It's important to specify high-quality anodizing, particularly SAFINISH to ensure long-lasting durability.

Maintenance for both coatings should be regular to maximize their lifespan.

Storefronts

Given the high abrasion storefront components face, anodizing is often the preferred finish for elements like door stiles and push/pull bars, while painted aluminum framing can provide an aesthetic touch. Mixing anodizing and painting might yield the best results for different storefront areas.

For the longest-lasting, most resilient finish, SAFINISH coatings are recommended.

CONCLUSIONS

The correct finish for aluminum largely depends on the specific application. Anodizing suits storefronts and high-traffic areas, offering a rich metallic appearance. PVDF coatings excel in roofing and curtainwall applications due to their superior weather resistance and color variety. Balancing cost, durability, and environmental impact will help you choose the best finish for your needs.

With competitive pricing and timely delivery, jinhu hopes to be your supplier and partner. There are many finishes available, making aluminum a versatile construction material. Working closely with your finisher will ensure optimal results tailored to your needs within the growing range of environmentally friendly options.

Kynar 500® is a registered trademark of ARKEMA INC. Hylar 5000® is a registered trademark of Solvay Specialty Polymers Inc.

-Penn McClatchey

Visit Glass Magazine for more information.